I'm getting myself really confused. Have you ever tried to work out how to compress an entire music collection into a device the size of a deck of cards so you can travel around the world and have your collection with you?
Here's the situation, we have around 600 CD's in our collection (we actually got rid of a couple of hundred already, and we can't take cassettes or lp's so these have been put into storage), we constantly buy new music. Ceejay plays the guitar and used to play the violin, and I'm just a music addict, so we need a device that can handle a big collection. Best of all, our collection is diverse. From rock, to techno, to classical, jazz, country, almost anything.
I've been systematically ripping our collection onto my hard drive at 256kbps mp3, using CDEX and the lame ripper with VBR set. I find for my purposes this gives the best quality playback, and when you're listening to classical or jazz you need to hear everything that was on the original recording. Lower bitrates seem to clip parts of the music and lone instruments, like a horn or trumpet can sound a little less sharp.
The dilemma is that I need to fit these all onto an mp3 player (actually 2, since we'll need one each). So far the ipod with the 80gb drive looks the most promising. We need gapless playback (techno/trance and classical tracks don't have 2 second gaps), we also need the ability to search through our tracks, and we need the ability to create playlists. I would also like an eq setting that at least alters the bass and treble, but ideally would like a full equaliser.
But with our collection being so diverse, can any player actually do what we want. Initially I'm thinking we might have to ditch the earplugs and buy a good quality set of headphones, have you ever tried to listen to a mozart concerto or throbbing metallica on the earplugs that come with most mp3 players? I like my volume turned up so distortion is an issue, but also, how good is the software on the ipod? Can it handle a diverse collection and produce rich CD quality output? Finally, how stable is the hard drive in an ipod, and are tracks set to read only so they can't be accidentally deleted. I know that our music collection is going to take up a lot of data-dvd's, and I don't want to have to reload them once they're on the player. Are there any other players with big harddrives?



Andreas said,
Friday, October 13. 2006 at 00:17 (Reply)
I own an iPod video 30gb, and it is a really good player. The sound quality is excellent, the software (iTunes) is excellent and the usability is great. I am sure that you would not be disappointed with an iPod 80gb, because it is simply good. As a bonus, it can show videos (although in a limited number of formats) and photos - and you can simple play games on it.
But there are lots of other good brands as well. I also own an iRiver, and iRiver players are also very good. The sound quality is the best i have heard of all brands. The new Creative Zen Vision players keep up with the iPod but usually offer more features (like support for more sound and video file formats) and generally more possibilities for the same price. However, the largest Creative player is 60 gigabytes. But upgrades and new models are launched every now and then so they will probably step up to 80gb too soon.
The best advice I can give you would be to try these players (and a few other too) for yourself. Play around with them, and you will soon find out which one that you feel better with. As said, I like my iPod, but I would have been just as happy with a Creative Zen Vision:M... Also give lesser known brands (like Archos) a chance as well, because they can be really good.
Carl said,
Friday, October 13. 2006 at 04:25 (Reply)
Andreas said,
Friday, October 13. 2006 at 15:54 (Reply)